Working parents prove ideal scenario

There is no evidence for a longer-term detrimental influence on child behaviour of mothers working during the child’s first year of life.

New research conducted at the ESRC-funded International Centre for Lifecourse Studies in Society and Health finds no significant detrimental effects on a child’s social or emotional development if their mothers work during their early years3. The ideal scenario for children, both boys and girls, was shown to be where both parents lived in the home and both were in paid employment.

For children living with two parents, the impact of the working life of the mother may partly depend on the father’s own working arrangements. However using data from the UK Millennium Cohort Study (MCS), the researchers discovered that the relationship between behavioural difficulties and employment of the mother was stronger for girls than for boys and that this was not explained by household income, level of mother’s education or depression in the mother.

While boys in households where the mother was the breadwinner displayed more difficulties at age five than boys living with two working parents, the same was not true for girls. Girls in traditional households where the father was the breadwinner were more likely to have difficulties at age five than girls living in dual- earner households.

Researcher Dr Anne McMunn has said: “Mothers who work are more likely to have higher educational qualifications, live in a higher income household, and have a lower likelihood of being depressed than mothers who are not in paid work. These factors explain the higher levels of behavioural difficulties for boys of non-working mothers, but the same was not true for girls.”

As previous research has indicated, children in single-mother households and in two-parent households in which neither parent was in work were much more likely to have challenging behaviour at age five than children where both parents were in paid employment. Household income, however, and maternal characteristics can mitigate the effects of this.

Poverty and parenting both matter